The Naming of Cats
Interestingly enough, it proved substantially harder to settle on a
name for the album than it was to choose many of the songs it would
include. After all, no single song was going to define the album, while
the name would be the first thing that many people had to form an opinion
about. It had to be catchy. Interesting. And, most importantly, it had
to fit the album.
This was going to require some thought.
Original Impressions
For a very long time, the plan was to call the studio album This Is My Town, thus giving it a very clear 'title song', and summing up the fact that most of the songs are sort of small-town-strange -- little pieces of places that probably never existed, but were somewhere you could see on a clear day when the wind was right. 'This Is My Town', 'Sycamore Tree', and 'Pretty Little Dead Girl' all happen in the same small town; 'Country Song' is the story of a small town with a big problem, and 'Take Advantage of Me' and 'Earthquake Weather' are set close enough to one another that you could argue for them sharing a township. It seemed like a good way to describe the album, quickly and without too much fuss.
Unfortunately, while some people very much liked the name, the ones who didn't like it really didn't like it. 'Egotistical', 'insipid' and 'too specific' were all phrases that came up during discussions of the album's name; several folks insisted that it was vain, because it claimed ownership of an entire town. (This kinda confused me, but you know what? My role in life is sometimes to accept that my perceptions come from an angle no one else knows how to find, and to react accordingly.) We needed a new name. But what to call the album?
Examining the various songs didn't prove as helpful as I've hoped, as none of them really jumped up and said 'me, me, I am the perfect song title'. Ironically, a lot of people liked the idea of calling the album Earthquake Weather, which would have been positively awesome, yes, if not for the Tim Powers book of the same name. D'oh. Almost as many suggested calling the album Still Catch the Tide, which was a bit problematic, given that 'Still Catch the Tide' is the only song on the album that I didn't actually write. Ooops.
I ran a series of online polls, looking for an album name, and found that people were divided along about a dozen different lines, all of which were logical and justified and made sense...and none of which were right. None of them said 'the album you have just made' to me, which was really where the big problem came in: I needed a name that defined the album. And I wasn't finding it.
Some Stars Fall Home
Without a well-defined 'title song', I began mining the lyrics of the songs confirmed for inclusion on the album, looking for something -- anything -- that spoke to me coherently of the album and what it meant.
I finally found what I was looking for when I got to 'Paper Moon', and the very first verse:
I don't want to live where the sky is small;
I want to write my name across the stars.
So you can follow me through all the ports of call,
You can hear my story in a thousand bars...
But that doesn't mean I'm gone for good;
Some stars fall home, and this one still could.
So tell my lover I could be home soon.
He can make his wishes on the paper moon.
That's what this album means to me. Maybe all stars eventually fall, but some of them get lucky; some of them fall home.
I did.
What do People Think the Title Means?
"It brings to mind the legend that stars are souls. When they fall, they're coming here to be born." -- Shades.
"I always think of it as meaning that sometimes falling isn't failure." -- Kate.
"I think of people who were meant to be wild and run...people who can't ever stay in one place...only falling 'home' after a long journey, or a long life in the place they were really meant to be." -- Vixy.
"Reunion sometimes makes leaving the sky behind worth it. I can't disassociate it from the song, so I can't help but see it both as a promise to have to leave for the sky and a promise that the reunion may be worth it, both." -- Mars.
"To me it means your wishes/dreams come back to you. They become real." -- Jeff.
"It puts me in mind of the night I laid out in the freezing winter to watch the meteor shower and wondered where all the shooting stars went when the stopped shining. No matter how far you go, you can always go home." -- Cat.
"It...makes me think about how fallen stars seem to be falling into nowhere but perhaps that's just the illusion of space and fallen stars are actually falling home...being embraced by the space they are falling into. Which I naturally translate into a metaphor in my head...I dunno if any of that makes sense! Just remember, you're the one who wanted a glimpse into my head and thinking." -- Rae.
"Your album's title makes no sense. YOU JUST PUT THREE WORDS TOGETHER, SEANAN. I'm going to call MY album Rocks Grab Sex." -- Sunil.
"When a star opens the door on its house, it trips over the doorway and lands flat on its face." -- Steve Mac.
"Coming home from Seattle, after a miserable failure of an attempt to relocate and the horrible things it did to my brain, seeing my father there to pick me up at the Greyhound station. My father, with whom I have never, ever gotten along, and who I've managed to set up a relationship of 'cordial disdain' with as the best of all possible options. Him taking me home while I was essentially badly broken and not telling me he was disappointed, not giving me shit -- first thing he said was 'welcome home' and the second thing was 'You know, I've got to say, I'm proud of you. It didn't work out, moving to Seattle, but even trying, that took more guts than I ever had.' I'll always love him for it. And that's what I think of every time I see the title...which may not be what you're looking for but it's true anyways." -- Shawn.